Can I Sue an Elderly Driver After an Accident in Fort Myers?

Table of Contents

Yes, you can sue an elderly driver after a car accident in Fort Myers. Still, under Florida’s no-fault auto insurance system, you must be able to prove negligence, and you must meet the serious injury threshold.

Elderly drivers are often experienced and careful, but age-related conditions like slower reaction times, vision impairments, or cognitive decline can lead to unintentional errors behind the wheel. When these errors cause serious harm to others, it’s critical to understand your legal rights, especially when dealing with delicate family dynamics or societal stigma surrounding elder accountability. Filing a claim is not about punishing someone for their age; it’s about ensuring your recovery and holding negligent parties accountable.

Our experiencedFort Myers car accident lawyer can guide you through the legal process and provide insights into the unique qualities of elderly drivers causing accidents.

Proving Negligence in Accidents Caused by Elderly Drivers

To file a lawsuit, you will still need to prove that the elderly driver was negligent.

Four Elements of Negligence

In practice, proving these elements requires more than a statement of facts. Your legal team must construct a narrative backed by admissible evidence. For instance, a “breach of duty” might involve an elderly driver running a red light due to confusion or delayed reflexes. “Causation” might be demonstrated through accident reconstruction experts who can prove that the driver’s failure directly led to your injuries.

You will need to demonstrate that the four elements of negligence were present:

Duty of Care: The elderly driver’s legal obligations to operate their vehicle safely and follow traffic laws
Breach of Duty: The action or inaction the elderly driver took that deviated from their obligations
Causation: The resulting accident and your injuries
Damages: The medical debt, lost income, physical pain, and emotional trauma you incurred

Evidence of Negligence

We prove those four elements with evidence, such as:

Police reports
Medical records
Witness statements
Photographs and video
Physical evidence
Expert witness testimony

When Age Can Affect Liability

In today’s legal landscape, technology can provide crucial support. Dashcam footage, GPS data, and even telematics from the vehicles involved can offer timestamped insights into speed, braking, or lane deviation. Additionally, eyewitnesses who noticed erratic driving behavior—such as drifting or delayed reactions—can provide essential context to build your case.

Age is not a defense against being held liable. However, the driver’s age may become relevant if they had:

Medical conditions that made them unfit to operate a vehicle
Records of prior driving infractions or license restrictions
Diminished capacity, an impaired mental state

Under these conditions, a third party, such as a caregiver, could be held liable. For instance, if a caregiver knew about the elderly driver’s medical conditions that made them unfit to operate a vehicle, or if they ignored signs of disorientation, prior accidents, or doctor recommendations to stop driving, they may share liability in the accident.

In some cases, caregivers or family members may be held responsible under the legal concept ofnegligent entrustment. This applies when someone knowingly allows a person unfit to drive due to physical or cognitive limitations to operate a vehicle. If a caregiver ignored signs of disorientation, prior accidents, or doctor recommendations to stop driving, they may share liability in the accident. Negligent entrustment is a legal theory that holds a person liable for entrusting their vehicle to someone they knew or should have known was unfit to drive.

Florida’s No-Fault Insurance System

In addition to proving negligence, you must meet specific legal requirements to file a lawsuit.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Coverage

Before you can file a lawsuit, you would first file an insurance claim under your PIP policy. All Florida drivers must carry PIP. PerFlorida Statutes § 627.736, you could receive the following benefits:

Medical Benefits: 80% of all necessary medical care
Disability Benefits: 60% of your gross income
Death Benefits: $5,000 per individual

Note that PIP is available regardless of fault but prohibits you from suing the at-fault driver.

Serious Injury Threshold

To meet the serious injury threshold, you’ll often need medical expert testimony and extensive documentation showing how your injuries have permanently impacted your body or life. This may include diagnostic imaging, surgical records, and statements from treating physicians. Without this evidence, the at-fault party’s insurer may argue that your injuries are temporary or minor, which can disqualify you from pursuing damages. Serious injuries under Florida law include those that result in significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death.

Florida Statutes § 627.737 provides exceptions under which you can sue the at-fault driver. There are:

Death
Permanent or significant scarring or disfigurement
Permanent or significant injury
Permanent or significant loss of bodily function

If your accident injuries meet these criteria, you can proceed with a lawsuit.

Florida’s Modified Comparative Fault

For example, if a distracted driver rear-ended you but you were partially blocking the road illegally, a court might assign you 20% of the fault. In this case, your potential compensation would be reduced by 20%. However, if it’s determined that you were 51% or more responsible, you would be barred from recovering damages entirely. This highlights the importance of working with an attorney who can build a strong liability case on your behalf.

We also need to consider that multiple parties could be at fault, such as a caregiver who failed to stop an impaired elderly adult from driving. UnderFlorida Statutes § 768.81, each party’s degree of fault is assessed and reduces the value of their settlement. However, any plaintiff whose degree of fault is greater than 50% is barred from receiving any compensation.

The aftermath of a car accident involving an elderly driver can be sensitive, not just legally, but emotionally. Whether the driver was a stranger or someone close to you, seeking justice is not an act of cruelty, but a necessary step to protect your rights and ensure your future well-being. Time is a critical factor. Evidence can be lost, witness memories can fade, and the legal window to act can close quickly.