How Auto Accident Settlements Can Exceed Insurance Policy Limits
In a car accident case, damages can sometimes exceed the policy limits of the at-fault driver’s insurance. This situation raises common questions such as what happens when car accident claim exceeds insurance limits or what happens if accident damage exceeds your car insurance. In Florida, insurance companies are generally only required to pay up to the coverage limits listed in the policy. However, that does not always mean your recovery stops there.
Under Florida accident laws, accident victims may have legal options for seeking auto insurance coverage above policy limit amounts when losses are substantial. Understanding what happens when a car accident exceeds policy limits is critical for protecting your financial future after a serious crash.
What Are Auto Insurance Policy Limits?
Florida law requires drivers to carry minimum insurance coverage, including:
-
$10,000 in Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
-
$10,000 in Property Damage Liability (PDL)
Florida does not require bodily injury liability insurance, but if a driver carries it, the minimum amount is typically $25,000. These minimum limits may cover minor crashes but are often insufficient in serious accidents involving hospitalizations, surgeries, or totaled vehicles.
When damages exceed these limits, many victims wonder will insurance pay more than policy limits. In most cases, insurers will not—unless special circumstances apply, such as bad faith handling or umbrella coverage.
How to Collect Damages Above an Auto Accident Insurance Settlement?
When a car accident exceeds policy limits, there are several ways to pursue additional compensation beyond the insurance payout.
- Multiple Liable Parties
If a commercial vehicle, rideshare driver, or government entity contributed to the crash, you may file claims against multiple parties. This is common in truck accidents, construction zone crashes, or defective roadway cases. - The At-Fault Driver Personally
If insurance coverage is inadequate, your attorney may pursue a lawsuit directly against the at-fault driver to recover damages beyond the policy limits, depending on available assets. - Umbrella or Excess Insurance Policies
Some drivers carry umbrella policies that provide coverage above standard auto insurance. These policies can apply when damages exceed the primary policy limits.
These options directly address concerns about what happens when car accident claim exceeds insurance limits and how victims can still recover compensation.
Are Some Accidents More Likely to Exceed Policy Limits?
Yes. Severe and catastrophic injuries are the most common reason auto accident settlements exceed policy limits. This helps explain how often do auto accident settlements exceed the policy limits, especially in cases involving:
-
Spinal cord injuries
-
Traumatic brain injuries (TBIs)
-
Amputations
-
Severe burns or permanent disfigurement
-
Long-term disability or loss of earning capacity
In these cases, medical bills alone can far exceed minimum coverage. Your lawyer must present strong evidence to justify compensation beyond insurance limits, including expert testimony and long-term financial projections.
Hit and Run Insurance Settlement Claims
A hit and run insurance settlement may also exceed policy limits, especially when punitive damages are available. In Florida, punitive damages may apply when a driver intentionally flees the scene or acts with gross negligence.
In hit-and-run cases, victims may rely on uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage to recover compensation when the at-fault driver cannot be identified or lacks sufficient insurance.
Who Pays Damages Beyond Policy Limits?
When damages exceed insurance coverage, responsibility may fall on:
-
The at-fault driver personally
-
Additional liable parties
-
The victim’s own UM/UIM policy
Although insurers usually do not pay beyond policy limits, courts can order individuals to pay damages following a successful lawsuit. This is especially relevant when people ask will insurance pay more than policy limits—the answer is usually no, but liability does not necessarily end with insurance.
How to Maximize Compensation When Damages Exceed Policy Limits
Victims may pursue several legal strategies, including:
-
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage (UM/UIM)
-
Bad Faith Insurance Claims, if the insurer unfairly refuses to settle
-
Negligence Claims Against Third Parties, such as manufacturers or government entities
-
Taking the Liable Party to Court, where juries are not bound by insurance limits
These approaches are key when seeking auto insurance coverage above policy limit amounts.
What You’re Entitled to in an Auto Accident Settlement
Your compensation depends on the severity of the crash and your losses. Damages may include:
-
Medical expenses (past and future)
-
Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
-
Pain and suffering
-
Property damage
-
Wrongful death damages
When a car accident exceeds policy limits, these damages often justify pursuing compensation beyond insurance coverage.
Understanding Insurance Types in Florida
Key insurance types under Florida accident laws include:
-
Bodily Injury Liability
-
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Knowing how these policies interact is essential when what happens if accident damage exceeds your car insurance becomes a reality.
Is There a Cap on Pain and Suffering in Florida?
Florida generally does not cap pain and suffering damages in negligence-based car accident cases. However, recovery is often limited by insurance policy limits unless additional claims or lawsuits are pursued. Government claims and sovereign immunity cases are subject to statutory caps.
How Much Will Your Auto Accident Settlement Be Worth?
Settlement value depends on injury severity, liability, insurance coverage, and available assets. An experienced Florida personal injury attorney can evaluate your case and explain whether compensation may exceed insurance limits.
If you’re facing a car accident exceeds policy limits situation, the Law Offices of Wolf & Pravato can help. Call (954) 633-8270for a free consultation. We work on a contingency basis—you pay nothing unless we win.
FAQs: Auto Accident Claims Exceeding Insurance Limits
1. What happens when a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits?
When a car accident exceeds policy limits, the insurance company only pays up to coverage limits, and you may pursue the at-fault driver or other liable parties for the remaining damages.
2. What is a car accident property damage settlement?
A car accident property damage settlement covers harm to your personal property. This can include:
- The cost of repairing your vehicle
- The cost of replacing your totaled vehicle
- The cost of replacing damaged property inside of your vehicle
- The cost of replacing personal property secured to the outside of your vehicle
A settlement may be necessary if property damage exceeds insurance coverage limits.
3. How do you find out someone’s insurance policy limits?
You should be able to learn someone’s insurance policy limits by contacting their insurance company. The company may generally contact you following your accident. In time, they should tell you what the at-fault party’s insurance policy limits are. We can handle this process for you. A Fort Myers car accident lawyer from our firm will inform you of the responsible party’s coverage limits once we learn them.
4. How much money can you get from a car accident settlement?
How much money you can get from a car accident settlement depends on:
- The value of your losses
- The effectiveness of your lawyer’s negotiation
- The willingness of at-fault parties to cover your losses
The American Bar Association (ABA) explains that liable parties generally agree to a settlement. There is no certain outcome to your case, however. As your case progresses, your lawyer will explain how much compensation they are targeting.
5. Will insurance pay more than policy limits in Florida?
In most cases, insurance will not pay more than policy limits under Florida accident laws, unless a bad faith claim or umbrella policy applies.